Skip down to the research record

Top sellers: 4 measures to compare with the team

Quota Forecast Editorial Team · Published · 12 min read

Compare top sellers with the team using talk share, customer sentiment, conversation switching and time by channel over the same weeks and call types.

Key takeaways

  • Define the top group independently of the measures you will review.
  • Match the time window, call types and minimum sample across groups.
  • Read the measures together before choosing a coaching question.
  • Check recordings and deal outcomes before changing a habit.

Forecast calls are where revenue leaders form their view of the quarter. A rep describes a deal, the buyer's reaction, the next step, and how sure they feel about the close date. The leader listens, adjusts, and sets a number. Over time, some reps' numbers prove more reliable than others'. When that happens, it is tempting to assume the top sellers know something the rest of the team does not, and to ask them to share their tricks in a meeting. That approach usually produces a few good stories and little change.

A more useful question can be measured. Do top sellers behave differently on the calls themselves? Call recording and analysis tools can describe how a call was run: who did most of the talking, how the customer seemed to feel, how often the conversation switches during customer calls, per hour, and where the seller's time went across channels. Those are the measures this post covers. They do not describe everything that makes a seller good, and they do not explain why a particular deal was won or lost. They give a leader a consistent way to see whether top sellers' calls look like the rest of the team's calls, and where they do not.

Set up the comparison before you pull numbers

Most comparisons go wrong at the setup stage, not in the arithmetic. Before you open a single report, decide four things.

First, who counts as a top seller. Pick a rule that does not depend on the call data you are about to examine, such as results against forecast over a fixed period. If you choose top sellers by how often they talk, the comparison becomes circular, and you will find that top sellers talk a lot because you selected them for it.

Second, the time window. Use the same weeks for both groups. A seller who joined mid-quarter, or who was out for part of it, can distort the picture, so either exclude them or note it clearly.

Third, the call types. Discovery, demo, negotiation, and renewal calls differ from one another, and a mix that is heavy on one type for one group will bias the numbers. Compare like with like wherever you can.

Fourth, the sample. A seller with only two calls in the window can produce an extreme average, so decide a minimum number of calls before you compare anyone. Set that minimum yourself, based on how many calls your team actually runs.

Write these four decisions down and keep them fixed for the whole review. That record matters later. It lets you explain why the numbers came out the way they did, and it stops you from changing the definition after you see a result you like.

A documented comparison to follow

This post follows one example from Microsoft's sales insights documentation. The page shows a team view in which top sellers are compared with the team on several call measures. The figures are the example values the documentation gives, and they make the reading method concrete. Your team's calls will produce their own numbers. The steps for reading them stay the same.

Measure 1: talk share against listen share

Start with how the call time splits between the seller and the customer. This measure compares how much the rep talks with how much they listen. A seller who does most of the talking leaves less room for the customer to explain priorities, objections, and timing. Those are the facts a forecast depends on. That is a reasonable hypothesis, but test it rather than assume it.

In the example, the gap is small. Top sellers talk 59 percent of the time against 61 percent for the team, and they listen 41 percent of the time against 39 percent (Microsoft's sales insights documentation). Each figure differs by two percentage points. Whether that matters depends on your team's baseline, but it points the question in a useful direction: in this example, top sellers let the customer speak a little more.

Talk share also says something about the seller's role in the call. Some calls are meant to be presentations, and a rep leading a product walkthrough should talk more than the customer. Others are meant to uncover needs, and there the listening side should dominate. Knowing which kind of call you are reviewing is the difference between a useful signal and a misleading one. A simple habit helps here: tag each call with its purpose when you review it, so that talk share is compared only between calls with the same job.

To check this on your team, pull the talk-to-listen split for the top group and for the rest of the team across the same calls. If the gap is tiny, do not spend coaching time on it. If it is large, check whether it sits in particular call types. Early discovery calls and late-stage commit calls should not look the same. Context changes what a number means.

Be careful with averages, too. Two sellers can share the same average talk share and run very different calls. If your tool shows the spread, look at it. Listen to a few calls at each end before you draw a conclusion.

Measure 2: customer sentiment

Sentiment asks how the customer seems to feel during the call. It is the measure most likely to surprise a leader, because it reflects the buyer's mood as much as the rep's behavior. A seller can run a sound process and still face a skeptical buyer, so read sentiment as a signal about the account and the conversation, not as a grade for the seller.

The example shows top sellers with 28 percent negative customer sentiment, compared with 26 percent for the team as a whole (Microsoft's sales insights documentation). In this example, top sellers' calls carry slightly more negative sentiment than the team's. That could mean they take on harder accounts, raise hard topics such as price or timing, or handle objections head on. It could also mean their calls are more candid about risk. The number alone cannot tell you which explanation applies.

Sentiment also has a timing question. A call that starts negative and ends positive tells a different story from a call that starts well and turns sour. If your tool shows sentiment across the length of the call, look at where it changes. A late drop can point to a concern that surfaced after the rep had already described the deal as healthy, which is exactly what a forecast review needs to catch.

For the forecast, this matters. A deal with visible resistance may still be real, but the forecast should reflect the risk the customer is showing. If top sellers regularly surface more negative sentiment, a leader may be getting an earlier and more accurate read, and the team could learn from that style instead of avoiding it. Test the idea against outcomes. Did deals with negative sentiment on calls close as often as the forecast expected? That check shows whether sentiment improves your forecast or only adds noise. For the deal review, use commit evidence checks to frame the follow-up.

Measure 3: switching during customer conversations

The third measure counts how often the conversation switches during calls with customers, expressed per hour. The documentation describes it in those terms. Before you use it, confirm the exact definition in your own tool. Read this number next to talk share, then listen to recordings to understand what the pattern means.

In the example, top sellers switch 33 times per hour, against 34 for the team (Microsoft's sales insights documentation). That is one switch fewer per hour, a very small gap. The lesson is not to chase a specific rate. It is that the rate is close, so in this example switching does little to separate top sellers from the rest.

There is also a coaching angle. A seller who switches rarely may be running long monologues, which can be fine in a scripted demo but unhelpful in a discovery call. A seller who switches often may be handling objections well, or may be interrupting. The number on its own does not separate those cases, so pair it with a few recordings before you decide what to change.

For your own team, ask whether the rate fits the call type. A discovery call and a pricing review should have different rhythms. If top sellers differ from the rest on switching only in one call type, you have a far more specific finding than a single team-wide average can give you.

Measure 4: where selling time goes by channel

The fourth measure looks at where a seller's customer time goes: email, phone calls, or meetings. It is broader than a call measure, but it shows whether top sellers spend their time the way the rest of the team does. A forecast built only from recorded calls can miss a great deal of the selling that happens in email threads and meetings.

The example reports that top sellers spend 23 hours on email, 1 hour on phone calls, and 6 hours in meetings (Microsoft's sales insights documentation). Email dominates. The example gives only the top sellers' figures, so it does not show how the rest of the team divides its time. It still makes a useful point: email time can exceed call time by a wide margin, and a leader who listens only to calls hears a small part of the work.

Channel mix also affects how you should read the forecast. A seller whose customer time sits mostly in email may have a deal history that never shows up on a call, so the call-based view of that deal is incomplete. Ask whether the sellers you consider top performers are the ones with the richest record across channels, or whether they simply talk more on the calls that get recorded. Check email logging rules when reviewing that record.

To use this measure, pull time by channel for both groups over the same weeks, then compare the shape, not only the totals. If top sellers spend much more time in meetings and less in email, ask what that means for how they move deals. If the mix looks alike, the channel is not where they differ, and you should weight the other three measures more heavily.

Reading the four measures together

Taken one at a time, each measure is a small signal. Taken together, they form a profile. In the example, top sellers talk slightly less and listen slightly more, carry slightly more negative sentiment, switch slightly less often, and spend most of their customer time in email. The three team comparisons each show a small gap, and none proves anything alone. Together they describe a team where top sellers' calls look close to the team's, with a few places worth examining.

One practical step is to put the four numbers side by side in a single view for each seller, rather than ranking sellers on each measure. Ranking invites a race to the top on the easiest number, such as talk share, while the harder numbers get ignored. A profile view lets a leader see which sellers resemble the top group, which ones differ, and in which direction.

That is an honest reading, and it is worth saying out loud to your own team. If your numbers look like the example, the gap in forecast accuracy may come from something the call measures do not capture, such as deal quality, account history, or how a rep updates the forecast after a call. If your numbers show a consistent difference on two or more measures, you have a specific hypothesis to test.

Watch for three traps. Small samples can produce gaps that look large. Averages can hide two different groups inside one team. And a difference between top sellers and the rest does not show that the habit causes the results. A seller may be top because of territory or account mix, and the call habit may be a side effect rather than a driver.

Illustrative example: check the call mix first

Suppose an illustrative review includes 20 calls for each group. Compare discovery with discovery and demos with demos before interpreting the overall talk-share gap. The totals match, but the call mix does not.

Turning the comparison into a forecast habit

Run this comparison on a regular schedule, such as once a quarter, or whenever you change the forecast process. Use the same four measures each time so that trends become visible. Share the findings with the team as questions to explore, not as a ranking.

When you find a real difference, test it. Pick one habit, such as asking more open questions, and coach it with one or two reps. Recheck the measure a few weeks later. A habit that moves the measure and improves forecast accuracy is worth keeping. A habit that moves the measure and nothing else is a lesson about the measure, not about selling.

It also helps to name who will act on each finding before the review starts. A difference in talk share is usually a coaching question for a sales manager. A difference in negative sentiment may belong to the forecast owner, who needs to decide how much weight to give a deal. Assigning the follow-up up front keeps the review from ending as an interesting chart that nobody changes anything about.

Finally, keep the people behind the numbers in view. Call data can help a leader see patterns, but a good forecast still depends on a rep being candid about a deal. Use these four measures to start better conversations, not to score anyone in public.

Start today

Write down your comparison groups, time window, call types and minimum sample, then pull talk share for matching calls to choose a question to investigate.

Questions about comparing top sellers

Does negative sentiment mean a seller is doing badly?

No; negative sentiment is a signal about the account and conversation, not a seller grade. Review where it changes and test its relationship with outcomes.

Can the channel-time example compare both groups?

No; it gives only the top sellers' channel hours. Pull the team's figures for the same weeks before comparing the mix.

Sources