Check commission payouts before quarter close for changed departure terms, deductions, returned payments, and plan terms below the required wage.
Key takeaways
- Compare departing reps' pending commissions with their original plan terms.
- Check proposed recoveries against the applicable deduction rules.
- Confirm funding and record when employees received and presented returned instruments.
- Review pay floors with counsel before approving payouts.
Why quarter close is the right time to check payouts
Quarter close is the right time because it is the last checkpoint before commission money moves. A problem found at this step can be addressed before approval. A problem found after payment has to be corrected after the money has moved.
This approval can involve sales operations, payroll, and the person who owns the commission plan. Each of them sees a different part of the picture, so the checks below are easier to follow when they are written down and assigned to someone.
A useful way to frame the review is to ask one question about each payout: could this payment be delayed, reduced, taken back, or returned because of how it was set up? If the answer is yes for any rep, that payout deserves a closer look before it is approved. The four mistakes below each map to one of those questions, and each is tied to a state rule that addresses it.
The rules differ from state to state, and each rule holds only in the state that wrote it. Where a quote below names a state, treat that rule as limited to that state. Do not carry it over to a rep who works somewhere else.
Minnesota's statute also says: "Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the application of other state or federal laws." Minnesota Statutes 181.03 In plain terms, a rule in one section does not replace the other laws that may apply to your team.
This post is general information, not legal advice. When a payout raises one of these questions, ask counsel who knows the state where the rep works.
Mistake 1: Changing how departing reps are paid
Under Minnesota's rule, an employer may not alter the method of payment, timing of payment, or procedures for payment of commissions earned through the last day of employment after an employee has resigned or been terminated, if the result is to delay or reduce the amount of payment. Minnesota Statutes 181.03
The rule opens with "Except as otherwise provided in section 181.13," so check that section before you treat any change as allowed. Ask counsel whether that exception covers your situation.
The same section also states the consequence: "An employer who violates this section is liable in a civil action brought by the employee for twice the amount in dispute." Minnesota Statutes 181.03 That exposure is the reason to check departures before the payout run, not after.
Quarter close is when departures and final payouts land on the same desk. A rep who left during the quarter may have deals that closed before the last day and deals that settled after it. Here is what to check:
- Make a list of every rep whose employment ended during the quarter. Record the last day of employment and the date of the resignation or termination.
- For each rep, find every pending commission and the schedule it is on. Compare that schedule with the plan document as it stood before the departure.
- Look for any change made after the departure: a later pay cycle, a new approval step, a different payment method, or a hold for further review. A change like these is what the Minnesota rule addresses when it delays or reduces a payment.
- Send any proposed change for a departed Minnesota rep to counsel before it goes out, even if the change looks small.
Ask counsel separately about commissions on deals that close after the last day of employment.
Communication with the departed rep matters too. If a payment date or method has to change, settle the terms with counsel before you tell the rep, and keep the written notice that goes out. Your records should show the original plan terms, the date of the departure, and the reason for any change. If you cannot show that a change was made on terms the rule allows, treat it as an open question for counsel.
Mistake 2: Taking money back from pay without checking deduction rules
Under Minnesota's statute, an employer may not deduct from an employee's wages for lost or stolen property, property damage, or claimed debts to the employer, directly or indirectly, except as permitted by section 181.79; this provision excludes independent contractors. Minnesota Statutes 181.14
Quarter close is when overpayments, errors, and charges can come up for review. If you plan to recover a commission overpayment, or a charge for equipment, by reducing a rep's next paycheck, check that step against this language first. A recovery that reduces wages by another route deserves the same check as one labeled a deduction.
Start with the rep's status. If the classification is unclear, settle it before any recovery is taken from pay.
Then sort each proposed recovery by its reason. Write the reason in plain words next to the amount. A recovery that does not fit one of the named reasons still deserves a check against the rule in the rep's state before it is taken.
Washington has a separate sentence on debts. It says: "Subsection (3) of this section shall not be construed to affect the right of any employer or former employer to sue upon or collect any debt owed to said employer or former employer by his or her employees or former employees." RCW 49.48.010 Read the full section before you rely on it for any recovery.
In practice, this means:
- Hold any recovery that would reduce a paycheck until it has been checked against the rule that applies in the rep's state.
- Write down the reason for each recovery, the amount, the rep's status, and the rule you checked.
- Use a second sign-off for any recovery from a Minnesota or Washington rep, since both statutes address recovering money from employees.
Mistake 3: Paying wages on an instrument that can be returned
Under Washington's rule, when an employer pays an employee's wages with an instrument defined by RCW 62A.3-104 that is returned for nonsufficient funds, the employer must reimburse the employee for the fee the employee's financial institution charged for the dishonored instrument if the employee presents it within 30 days of receiving it. RCW 49.48.010
The same section also says the employer is not liable for those fees in one case: "if the employer presents written confirmation by the employer's financial institution that the instrument was returned for nonsufficient funds due to an error." RCW 49.48.010 Check that written confirmation before relying on the exception.
This matters for commission runs because a payout can be released as one batch. A funding gap can return several payments at once, and each returned payment has its own dates and its own questions. Before the run goes out:
- Confirm that the funding account covers the full payout run before release. Keep a record of that check.
- Record when the employee originally received the instrument and when the employee presented it, so you can check the 30-day window.
- If an instrument was returned for nonsufficient funds due to an error, ask the bank for written confirmation.
- If a Washington rep reports a bank fee for a returned payment, check the date the rep presented the instrument against the 30-day limit before you decide what to do.
Bank fees are one piece of a returned payment. Your records should also show the original payout amount, the date it was sent, the date it came back, and what was done to correct it. A clear record makes the 30-day question easy to answer if a rep asks, and it keeps the funding decision separate from the payroll decision.
Mistake 4: Writing plan terms that pay below the required wage
Maryland's statute reads: "An agreement to work for less than the wage required under this subtitle is void." Maryland General Assembly, Laws - Statute Text, section 3-502
For the required wage and its application to your commission plan, use the subtitle itself and counsel. Do not fill in a figure from memory.
A pay floor is any plan term that sets the least a rep will be paid in a period, such as a guaranteed minimum that applies before commission is calculated. If your plan has one, check it against the subtitle. If your plan has none, a check is still useful, because the amount a rep is paid depends on which deals settle in the period.
Quarter close is when plan terms meet actual payouts. A term that reads well on paper can produce a payout that needs a second look once real numbers are applied. For each Maryland rep:
- Pull the plan document and every term that sets a minimum amount or pay floor.
- Ask whether any term could lead to pay below the wage the subtitle requires. Get the figure from the subtitle, not from a summary.
- If the answer is unclear, send the question to counsel before the payout is approved, not after it is paid.
- Keep the review notes with the version of the plan that was checked, so you can show what was reviewed and when.
Build the review into your quarter-close sign-off
Put the four checks into one written sign-off for each payout run. A written record keeps the checks from depending on anyone's memory, and it shows what was reviewed for each rep.
Set the review deadline ahead of the payout run, not on the day of it. If counsel's answer is needed, the run cannot be approved until that answer arrives, so the time to ask is early in close.
For related close work, use the bookings reconciliation checks and commission accrual checks.
A simple sign-off can follow this order:
- Departures. List each rep who left during the quarter, the dates, the pending commissions, and whether any payment timing or method changed afterward. This covers Mistake 1.
- Recoveries. List every amount taken from pay or reserved for recovery, with the rule checked and the second sign-off. This covers Mistake 2.
- Funding. Confirm the funding check for the run, and log each returned instrument with the employee's original receiving date and presentment date. This covers Mistake 3.
- Plan terms. Confirm that the pay terms for each rep were compared with the wage rule in that rep's state. This covers Mistake 4.
- State. Record the state where each rep works.
Name an owner for each item. A sales operations lead, a payroll lead, and counsel may each sign a different line. Keep a copy of the plan document as it stood on the approval date, so the review can be tied to the terms that were in force.
Illustrative example: Check the payment dates
An employee presents an instrument 10 days after originally receiving it, and it is returned for nonsufficient funds. Record both dates and the bank fee. Compare the elapsed time with Washington's 30-day condition, then check for written bank confirmation of an error before deciding on reimbursement.
Before you approve the run
Finish the four checks, and get counsel's answer on anything you cannot settle, before you approve the payout.
Use this post as a list of questions to ask before you approve a payout. Take the answers to counsel who knows where your reps work, and keep a record of what you checked. That record is what lets you show the review was done when the quarter closes.
When you share the outcome with the people who sign the payout, say which checks were completed, which questions went to counsel, and which payouts were held. A short summary of that kind lets the approver act on a written record instead of a verbal assurance.
Today, choose a pending payout run, assign an owner to each sign-off item, and gather the plan documents before approval.
Related guides: 4 Stripe renewal date rules to check before quarter close · Accepted quote review: 6 checks at quarter close.
Questions before approval
Which state should the review record?
Record the state where each rep works. Ask counsel which rules apply to that rep's payout.
What should accompany the payout sign-off?
Keep the plan version, review notes, payment dates, and any counsel responses with the sign-off. Give the approver a written summary of unresolved questions.